-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
Expedition Everest's Devil's Advocate
- Thread starter Scott M
- Start date
pintraderpayee
Active Member
jvenegas said:
wannab@dis said:Merlin... please keep your remarks about EE in this thread... there's no need to get off topic in totally unrelated threads in your attempt to bash EE.
http://forums.wdwmagic.com/showpost.php?p=1540708&postcount=7
Is this the only thread that exists on the topic of EE? If the answer is "no" then I have just as much right as you have to post in other threads on the same topic.
peter11435
Well-Known Member
I love how now that I have posted a list of Merlin quotes where he is clearly trying to "say what the majority of people think" he chooses to ignore them altogether.
Merlin said:
Merlin, why is it that the vast majority of your posts here seem to be focused around bashing your point of view down peoples throats in a never ending cycle. You have been warned about this before. You have your opinion, and that is fine, but you seem to enjoy ruffling peoples feathers, and generally seem to be looking for arguments. If you cannot accept other members views without questioning everything over and over and looking for an argument, I think you should go elsewhere.
OmegaKnight said:
I had a little down time and decided to check one of my favorite sites and what do I find...a post about Disney vacationers being disappointed with Everest. Remember, he said these folks travel to Disney on a regular basis, so they are not looking for Six Flags thrills. That is not why they were disappointed with the ride.
I have taken at least 15 people on Everest. About 7 of them work with me in themed entertainment design. Every one of them thought it was okay but nothing to write home about. 5 of them were very disappointed in the lack of show during the ride. Regarding the non-industry riders, half of them loved it and the other half thought it was medicore. Most everyone really enjoys the backwards sequence, including myself.
I won't argue that most people get off Everest and think it's great. Not difficult to build a ride that the public enjoys when you have $100 Million to spend. It's a roller coaster for crying out loud! People will enjoy it no matter what you do. If they like BTMR they will like Everest. That is basically all it is with fewer show elements in the ride portion. Jeesh...there are only 3 show elements in the attraction! Why are so many making a big deal over a video projector, mangled track and one Animatronic with ancillary lighting? That's it? So the money went into a nice mountain and a bunch of knick knacks in the queue. I feel the same way about Kali...there is almost as much detail in its queue and it doesn't make the ride worth 2 cents in my opinion. I'm glad they spent the time and money on the Everest exterior, it's a nice addition to Animal Kingdom and does much for its ambiance. Too bad such a low percentage of the budget went into the ride show.
All in all, I don't think this project advanced the Disney repertoire of attractions with respect to innovation or presentation any more then Philarmagic or Stitch. Some will love it because it's a roller coaster but it doesn't live up to the hype in my opinion and in many others' opinions that I've talked to.
peter11435
Well-Known Member
Yes I did.Merlin said:
Examples of Merlin trying to say what the majority of people think.
Merlin said:
Merlin said:
Merlin said:
Merlin said:
Merlin said:
SpongeScott
Well-Known Member
Peter, let it go. Steve's aware of what is happening now. Let's let him deal with it in his way. :wave:peter11435 said:
peter11435
Well-Known Member
Yeah, I think I will. I just can't stand him repeatedly saying I falsely accused him.SpongeScott said:
wannab@dis
Well-Known Member
He's the only one that thinks that. Everyone else can see the truth. :wave:peter11435 said:
ClemsonTigger
Naturally Grumpy
fundesign said:
Very nice post. It's a shame others can approach discussion in the same way that you do, by providing your observation and opinions while respecting others theirs.
Pete C
Active Member
It is very disappointing to watch the building of a ride, listen to the hype, and hope for an attraction to be great, then read several reviews that say it is mediocre. I am riding EE in June, but after reading reviews posted on this forum my excitement level has dropped considerably.
wannab@dis
Well-Known Member
Honestly, the majority of reviews I've seen here (and elsewhere also) has been very positive. Don't let a couple of vocal detractors change your excitement about experiencing a new attraction. Just go down and give EE a try without worrying about what others say... good or bad.Pete C said:
SpongeScott
Well-Known Member
Before M:S opened and I read all the reviews and hype, I was almost tired of the ride before I ever went on it. With EE, I refused to read any of the hype and early previews. Therefore, I went and rode with no pre-conceived ideas about it and really enjoyed it. I'll not read the hype stuff on new attractions that come out in the future.Pete C said:
Senderella
Member
OmegaKnight said:
Definately! I've only been on it once. The day we checked in actually.. Feb 12. 2 Hour wait. I've gotta say I loved it. Most rides like ToT & all have me grinning & laughing like a maniac. This one actually got a scream out of me. As soon as I got off the ride, I grabbed my cell and called my best friend (who is going with us in November for the first time ever) and TOLD him "We are *SO* going on EE in November!! No ifs ands or buts!"
Thanks. I'm not purposely trying to be diplomatic but if there's one thing I've learned being in the design field...it's all subjective. I've met people that think Spiderman or Indy ride are just "okay." While it boggles my mind I've realized that nothing I say will change most opinions. Same goes for this project. I find helpful to speak out so as to solidify my thoughts and who knows, at the same time maybe one or two might see things in a different light.ClemsonTigger said: