Would you rather go to Tutto Italia or Mama Melrose?

[One Lil Spark]

Weigh in on the poll and let's hear the reasons why! :wave:

 

[cdunbar]

I've heard many negative things about Mama Melrose's and I wouldn't want you to have a bad meal on your Disneymoon....:kiss:

 

[Victoria]

Neither. :lookaroun I can get mediocre Italian food anywhere (and some really excellent food at home too). There are far better places worthy of a DDP TS credit.

 

[blackthidot]

Tutto...Its not even close.

 

[DMC-12]

While I tend to agree with V... I am gonna have to go with Mama Melrose between the two.

 

[disDUBney]

Tutto Italia, the food is really good.

 

[laynalee07]

Mama Melrose!!!.. Tutto has had the worst service the times we have been there and the food was just medicore... i also love the atmosphere in Mama's so much better...

 

[tampabrad]

Neither, I can get dog food at Publix.

 

[DMC-12]

Mama Melrose!!!.. Tutto has had the worst service the times we have been there and the food was just medicore... i also love the atmosphere in Mama's so much better...

Ditto.. its (way) below Olive Garden standards... IMO. :lol::lookaroun:lookaroun

 

[lighteningqueen]

Tutto was great in Dec. Not our best meal but a good meal. Nothing beats a good Zio's though. ANYTHING is way better than Olive Garden, now there we are talking dog food..

 

[laynalee07]

We also went to Tutto in Dec... i wish our experience would have been great also...

 

[lighteningqueen]

I see you are from Ft Worth then you should know about Zio's.. There is nothing better than that restaurant and once you go there you tend to compare big time. In Dec I had the Caprese and husband had some lamb thing. Went all out never eats that stuff he said it was great. Our lady server was really good and like I said or did not say. It was good and from what I heard we made the right choice on the two. But our best was Teppon now that is yummmmmmmmmmm

 

[laynalee07]

I havent heard of Zio's but I will have to look into it... We also LOVED Teppan Edo (spelling?)... we went there in Dec. for our frist time.

I think the thing with Tutto was we were one of the last guests to be sat for the night (we even got there 20 minutes before our reservation) and they were trying to rush us the whole time. They would also stand against the wall and just stare us down, waiting for us to leave... and its not like we were lingering around.. we were in and out in about 40 minutes! Maybe less. They were also breaking down all the tables all around us (taking off dirty tablecloths and shaking them out) RUDE!!!!

 

[OklaHoops]

MM vs Tulio

Neither! Alfredos was better than both. They had the best Fettuccine ever!

 

[OklaHoops]

By the way, Zios is Mazzio Pizza trying to sell up. Good prices, pretty good food. Atmosphere blah!:snore:

 

[zurgandfriend]

We like Tutto more that Mama’s. I thought Mama’s had a lot of “Red Sauce” items on their menu where as Tutto has much more selection.

 

[Hakunamatata]

Been to Mama Melroses a couple of times and was never impressed. Food cold and not all that good.

 

[lighteningqueen]

Zio's is on 35 about 2 exits North of 820 They have an on line web site just type it in and it wilol tell where it is at. No they are not a Mazzios. Nothing like that. Very good food and the one in Oklahoma City is not as good as the one in San Antonio or Tulsa. We just ate at OKC when we came to sell at the Affair of the Heart show.

 

[Lucky]

Neither, I can get dog food at Publix.

Yeah, but in all the times I've been to Publix I've never seen Illuminations once. Maybe I don't go at the right time.

 

[Pumbas Nakasak]

Neither for me. Good Italian food at WDW is rarer than a Pluto poo. Mama Mel has to be the most inconsistent restaurant at Disney and as a result not worth taking a risk on given the inflated prices.