Which of the following highly rated WDW restaurants has the best Food Quality?

[correcaminos]

I have yet to eat at V&A because literally too much food for me. Being kid sized suck sometimes lol. I meant to do Tiffins this year but we see how that went...

so out of the ones I have been to I picked Skipper Canteen weirdly enough. Quality of food has been great and their ability to work with my allergy was top notch.

Sanaa is decent though felt the menu changes were for the worse over the last few years.
Flying Fish was ho hum to us
Raglan Road was okay in both service and food quality.
Jiko is really good too but we don't go often enough
Ohana has not been good in like decades
Hollywood Brown Derby & Le Cellier are just not good at all. Really not good.

 

["El Gran Magnifico"]

Okay, so while technically not officially "on-property" - the only way you can get there is from "on-property" - so I consider it "unofficially on-property" - Bull and Bear. Never had a bad meal there. Shula's ain't bad either.

 

[Hockey89]

Okay, so while technically not officially "on-property" - the only way you can get there is from "on-property" - so I consider it "unofficially on-property" - Bull and Bear. Never had a bad meal there. Shula's ain't bad either.

bull and bear is good.

 

[Sirwalterraleigh]

I had to write it out to figure out my vote. Out of what I've written below, Tiffins is first, followed by Jiko. Le Cellier was last for me.

• Flying Fish - Excellent, but can't vote for it b/c my last experience was prior to the overhaul.
• Sanaa - Consistently good and a must on most trips, but it's bread service that keeps us coming back.
• Raglan Road - Not impressed.
• Jiko - Excellent, but it was just me and with my dietary stuff, I like to see what DH thinks.
• Ohana - Used to be good (not best), but last visit had all kinds of issues.
• Victoria and Albert's - Someday...if I could get DH to dress up this much on vacation.
• Skipper Canteen - Hopefully next trip.
• Tiffins - Excellent and before my dietary changes.
• The Hollywood Brown Derby - Very good, but never wow for us.
• Le Cellier - Have yet to have a decent meal here.

Wow...this lines up with me completely...and I’ve been to the vast majority of wdw sitdowns 5 or 10+ times.

 

[Sirwalterraleigh]

Okay, so while technically not officially "on-property" - the only way you can get there is from "on-property" - so I consider it "unofficially on-property" - Bull and Bear. Never had a bad meal there. Shula's ain't bad either.

Don’t cross the streams, Egon!!

 

[Hockey89]

Wow...this lines up with me completely...and I’ve been to the vast majority of wdw sitdowns 5 or 10+ times.

I agree with most of it outside of The Brown Derby. It’s so blah and overpriced. The service has been sucky too.

 

[Sirwalterraleigh]

I agree with most of it outside of The Brown Derby. It’s so blah and overpriced. The service has been sucky too.

I know brown derby is hit or miss...but I still enjoy it. It’s not as good as it once was.

But if that was the criteria...i couldn’t go anywhere.

Skippers is meh...by the way.

Ohana is one of the most overrated restaurants in wdw.

Le cellier is the most overrated restaurant in THE world

 

["El Gran Magnifico"]

Don’t cross the streams, Egon!!

 

[Hockey89]

I know brown derby is hit or miss...but I still enjoy it. It’s not as good as it once was.

But if that was the criteria...i couldn’t go anywhere.

Skippers is meh...by the way.

Ohana is one of the most overrated restaurants in wdw.

Le cellier is the most overrated restaurant in THE world

Skippers isn’t bad for a lunch spot which is when we go. It’s fine.

Le Cellier is the most overrated place ever. It’s sucks

 

[Sirwalterraleigh]

Skippers isn’t bad for a lunch spot which is when we go. It’s fine.

Le Cellier is the most overrated place ever. It’s sucks

I’ve found skippers to be “adequate”...which is ok

Le cellier surfaced straight from the 6th layer of suck in hell

 

["El Gran Magnifico"]

Skippers isn’t bad for a lunch spot which is when we go. It’s fine.

Le Cellier is the most overrated place ever. It’s sucks

Completely agree on Skippers. I used to duck out of Epcot and hit Yachtsman when I wanted steak. Even Yachtsman isn't what it was. Now, I prefer Shula's. Though it kinda s*cks 'cause I could go back into the park after a meal a Yachtsman. If I hit Shula's it's a 7:30 - 8:00pm res and I'm going right back to the hotel afterwards.

IMO - they need a Haunted Mansion Steakhouse. And have it run by a third party - a good one. So, So, So much they could do with that. It'd be $300-500 for a family of Two-to-Four - and they'd be turning away people. And they could serve Absinthe.

 

[Tony the Tigger]

For MK, Skippers is a nice addition with some good dishes at a reasonable price point. It is more of a lunch spot for us, also.

Never been to Le Cellier.

Flying Fish just about broke my heart when they changed chefs (and ruined the place.)

I have the recipe for their potato wrapped snapper in a recipe book, but it’s very intimidating!

Tried 3 times with the new chef, all disappointing.

 

["El Gran Magnifico"]

Flying Fish just about broke my heart when they changed chefs (and ruined the place.)

Every (well almost) time I head out thinking I'm going - I end up with an appetizer at Boardwalk Joe's and then find myself at the Pizza Window. Then I sit there eating my pizza and watching ducks float by.

I agree with you. It used to be much better.

 

[Sirwalterraleigh]

For MK, Skippers is a nice addition with some good dishes at a reasonable price point. It is more of a lunch spot for us, also.

Never been to Le Cellier.

Flying Fish just about broke my heart when they changed chefs (and ruined the place.)

I have the recipe for their potato wrapped snapper in a recipe book, but it’s very intimidating!

Tried 3 times with the new chef, all disappointing.

Every (well almost) time I head out thinking I'm going - I end up with an appetizer at Boardwalk Joe's and then find myself at the Pizza Window. Then I sit there eating my pizza and watching ducks float by.

I agree with you. It used to be much better.

I won’t go to flying fish anymore...

And change happens...chefs move on. I get that.

It’s the dining plan driven “investment” required now. When dinner for two is in the $150+ range BEFORE the 3 old fashioned I need to cope with the heat?? I’m not willing to have a “miss” meal. I don’t get misses in well run restaurants elsewhere. Or crappy service...to be honest.

 

[Hockey89]

For MK, Skippers is a nice addition with some good dishes at a reasonable price point. It is more of a lunch spot for us, also.

Never been to Le Cellier.

Flying Fish just about broke my heart when they changed chefs (and ruined the place.)

I have the recipe for their potato wrapped snapper in a recipe book, but it’s very intimidating!

Tried 3 times with the new chef, all disappointing.

It’s a shame they got rid of the snapper. Legit was a great dish. Not just for Disney but a great dish. I haven’t been back since they changed.

 

["El Gran Magnifico"]

I won’t go to flying fish anymore...

And change happens...chefs move on. I get that.

It’s the dining plan driven “investment” required now. When dinner for two is in the $150+ range BEFORE the 3 old fashioned I need to cope with the heat?? I’m not willing to have a “miss” meal. I don’t get misses in well run restaurants elsewhere. Or crappy service...to be honest.

The DDP is the worst option. I agree there. I'm just hoping that Manny's Chophouse off of 535 is still open when I go back later this month. I swear that is the best burger I think I've ever had. I'm hitting Lego first. So I'm trying that Manny's first.

 

[Tony the Tigger]

We are hoping to just go do a resort dinner soon, stay overnight either on property or with family in Melbourne.

What I wouldn’t give for a wild boar appetizer at Jiko right now! (I know, they haven’t reopened yet.) Looking at options. Not likely to do park tix.

 

[Sirwalterraleigh]

It’s a shame they got rid of the snapper. Legit was a great dish. Not just for Disney but a great dish. I haven’t been back since they changed.

In my opinion...they’re getting soft. Why just get rid of the signature dish when you can literally just destroy the whole restaurant a la Artists Point??

 

[Tony the Tigger]

In my opinion...they’re getting soft. Why just get rid of the signature dish when you can literally just destroy the whole restaurant a la Artists Point??

The whole menu changed. I remember an employee telling me the best thing on it was a chicken dish (at a seafood restaurant.)

The redesign of the place itself was very nice.

 

[Lord Starwalker]

Well, it looks like we will have to give Jiko another try. Last time we dined there, we were not that impressed (it was good but we enjoyed Sanaa more). Perhaps they have improved the menu since then.