BoG is just a restaurant. With better theme but the same food.
Realistically, how often will I eat there? I can only do so many tables service meals in one holiday. I'll go cvjheck it out, and then eat tyhere again maybe another trip.
Rides though, I do over and over, every single trip. So TLM for me. I like me a darkride too, and I enjoyed the videos I've seen of it. (Except for the rushed ending etc etc) TestTron I'm also looking forward too, but not hugely so - I never liked TT. It doesn't really do anything for me.
Also: what, no mention of Jack Sparrow? And Disney is building an entire * cough * attraction for him, the hottest thing of like forty years ago!