I think you missed a very important thing. If wall street loves comcast so much more than Disney, why is comcast market cap 136.1 billion while Disney is 144.26 billion? I guess wall street does love Disney. Wall Street gives Disney a higher PE because they believe Disney profits will grow faster. Why? I thought everyone knew Universal was blowing everyone away in theme parks and profits and that next gen was a financial sink hole. Maybe they know next gen is working and will make huge profits freeing capital for more expansion? No one can deny high PE shows investors are betting their money that Disney is Growing faster than Universal.
Comcast's P/E is about 19. Disney's P/E is about 21. In the grand scheme of things, that's not much of a difference. I wouldn't say Wall Street loves either one more.
As
@GoofGoof notes, Parks are a small fraction of Comcast's business. It gets some headlines but it barely registers in Comcast's stock price. P&R makes up a much bigger percentage of Disney's revenue. Much more than Comcast, Disney is in the theme park business.
WWOHP cost slightly more than half the New Fantasyland yet had a transformational effect on Uni's Parks. It produced explosive growth and so Wall Street wants to talk about it. They think Diagon Alley will be the same.
Disney's P&R hasn't experienced that kind of immediate growth since EPCOT opened in 1982. That's not bad. Disney's P&R is a lot bigger. It's not going to have that kind of growth ever again. (Neither will Comcast.) Instead, Disney's P&R needs to come up with a strategy to realize sustainable double-digit growth.
So far, MyMagic+ ain't it. Its problems are threefold.
First, it's complicated. Complicated means difficult to sell. Just look at the 30-second spots Disney tried to run for it. To someone who wasn't already familiar with the concept, the ads don't make sense. Now contrast that to the ads for SDMT. The message is simple: "new rollercoaster". This summer, there's a decent chance SDMT will result in more business than MyMagic+.
People who visit WDW might love MyMagic+ but that really doesn't matter. The question is whether it produces new business. So far, Iger continues to be publically cautious with MyMagic+ guidance. No one at Disney is claiming MyMagic+ is a financial success yet.
Even Wall Street can't figure out MyMagic+ financially. That's why they've asked questions about it for 6 straight quarters.
Second, MyMagic+ is expensive to develop. Disney has spent far more on MyMagic+ than Universal will have spent on WWOHP, Transformers, the Simpson's Land redo, and Diagon Alley
combined. Disney made one big-budget movie. Universal made several small films, one of which already has turned into a blockbuster. MyMagic+ is going to have to produce a lot more increased revenue just to cover costs.
Third, MyMagic+ is coming after 3 years of combined price increases of about 25%. It's difficult for paying customers to absorb that kind of increase and then be expected to spend even more as a result of MyMagic+. If MyMagic+ had rolled out 3 years ago and then Disney began these price increases, then it might have been possible to claim success. However, coming after 3 years of significant price hikes, MyMagic+ will face an uphill battle to add additional revenue. The timing of the rollout of MyMagic+ is pretty bad.
We need to give MyMagic+ a few more quarters to see what result it ultimately has on earnings. However, if by this time next year there's no appreciable change in P&R's numbers, then MyMagic+ will have turned into another
John Carter or
Lone Ranger.