The WDWMAGIC review page for Idol is at http://www.wdwmagic.com/Attractions/The-American-Idol-Experience/Reviews.htm
We'd love to have your review. Thanks!
We'd love to have your review. Thanks!
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
Seen American Idol? Leave us your review
- Thread starter wdwmagic
- Start date
nemofinder22
Well-Known Member
I went in with pretty low expectations. To my surprise it was pretty well done, theres some great guest interaction even if your not up on stage. The hosts were great but the judges were even better. Wasnt a big fan of the part when they wanted the audince to dance along but I did like the music video with Jordan Sparks. It was much better than I expected lots of fun and really cool to see the stage in person granted its smaller than the one in real life.
disney3371
New Member
American Idol
I went with 4 friends and we thought it was really bad i give 2 years before its closed my friends said 1 year the warm up guy is the worst not funny and some really bad jokes i dont if it becuase i work in the muisc bussiness but the actors here are bad the randy look alike is bad the paula wanna be looks like a washed up debbie gibson and the simion looks a really bad jay leno the people performing were ok but they spent most of the time looking at the back of the theather looking at the words on the back wall. the place was half filled when toy story mania was still 80 mint wiat I say yes to more rides and no this kind of stuff if you have to wiat on a long line to see this get off if theres no wiat chekc it out :shrug:
I went with 4 friends and we thought it was really bad i give 2 years before its closed my friends said 1 year the warm up guy is the worst not funny and some really bad jokes i dont if it becuase i work in the muisc bussiness but the actors here are bad the randy look alike is bad the paula wanna be looks like a washed up debbie gibson and the simion looks a really bad jay leno the people performing were ok but they spent most of the time looking at the back of the theather looking at the words on the back wall. the place was half filled when toy story mania was still 80 mint wiat I say yes to more rides and no this kind of stuff if you have to wiat on a long line to see this get off if theres no wiat chekc it out :shrug:
jt04
Well-Known Member
Welcome to the boards! Did you register just to post a review or can we expect lots more great contributions?
I'm a bit lost but what is "the simion"?
Club Cooloholic
Well-Known Member
If you use your powers of comprehension, and think of the context of the post, you should be able to figure out what they meant. It might require a little effort, but I think you can do it.
Disneyfan506
New Member
All I have to say saw it twice and ITS REALLY COOL!
It is a must see!
It is a must see!
gardener14
Member
Deleted review, and added it to review page where it belongs.
lorinmike2728
New Member
Was there last week. Saw the finale show 2 x's. My family and I actually enjoyed it. You kind of have to go in with the mindset that you are not going to see the actual Idol show but a sort of Disney version of it. I was actually quite impressed with most of the singers that we saw. The show we saw on 1/26/08 had a girl perform who was excellent, they said they were actually giving away the first real golden ticket that night, I do not know if they actually did or not but there was no announcement that there had been on the Satuday show that these were Disney employees of affiliates of Disney. Overall I really enjoyed myself both times. The kick off host was really funny.
Hi guys,
If you could add your reviews to the review page for Idol at http://www.wdwmagic.com/Attractions/The-American-Idol-Experience/Reviews.htm
That keeps them all together, and adds to the overall rating score of the attraction.
This thread was just to let you know that page was there, not to post the review in. Thanks!
If you could add your reviews to the review page for Idol at http://www.wdwmagic.com/Attractions/The-American-Idol-Experience/Reviews.htm
That keeps them all together, and adds to the overall rating score of the attraction.
This thread was just to let you know that page was there, not to post the review in. Thanks!
wdwmemories
New Member
I have an Annual Passholder ticket to see it this weekend - I'll let you know what I think, and will hopefully have some pictures too!
NeNe1298
New Member
My family and I saw the 4pm show and the finale show on February 4th. We enjoyed the winner of the 4pm show so much we went back to see if she could win the golden ticket and she did. I believe she will do very well on the actual show. My daughter loved her, she actually got her autograph.
As for the attraction, it's good. We liked the warm up guy, Mark. The guy who is supposed to be Ryan S. didn't really know his lines and kept looking up at the teleprompter. The judges were ok. I liked them better in the finale show, they were more serious and dressed better.
We will definately go again. We found the show very entertaining.
As for the attraction, it's good. We liked the warm up guy, Mark. The guy who is supposed to be Ryan S. didn't really know his lines and kept looking up at the teleprompter. The judges were ok. I liked them better in the finale show, they were more serious and dressed better.
We will definately go again. We found the show very entertaining.
I seen it in late jan. I thought it was pretty good. Scale of 1-10 about a
7 1/2 or 8. The set was done real well. Judges were not that bad. Keep it all in context. The best part of the attraction is the singers.There were some decent performers. And isnt that the point. American Idol has alot of fans, this attraction should do as well as the show does. When the show "jumps the shark" as goes the attraction.
7 1/2 or 8. The set was done real well. Judges were not that bad. Keep it all in context. The best part of the attraction is the singers.There were some decent performers. And isnt that the point. American Idol has alot of fans, this attraction should do as well as the show does. When the show "jumps the shark" as goes the attraction.
Retrorides
New Member
Nope, not a clue and I've seen the show (at the Studios, never on TV). Those names mean nothing. Also the run on sentences make it even more incomprehensible.
orlando210
Member
pleasantly surprised
just back from a week with the mouse, and wanted to comment on Idol. we went on Sat. 2/14 for the 'Grand Opening' day, and while I don't have much interest myself, my 2 teenage daughters love the show.
with no expectations, i thought that the production was very well done. i think it might be tough to keep getting qualified contestants on a long-term basis, but the show was entertaining, and the set was impressive.
just back from a week with the mouse, and wanted to comment on Idol. we went on Sat. 2/14 for the 'Grand Opening' day, and while I don't have much interest myself, my 2 teenage daughters love the show.
with no expectations, i thought that the production was very well done. i think it might be tough to keep getting qualified contestants on a long-term basis, but the show was entertaining, and the set was impressive.
on_the_monorail
New Member
I saw it on 2/14 and was actually quite impressed.
My dad and I had been joking about it all day, and when we walked by we decided "Hey, why not give it a try?".
I probably won't go to it a lot, but if I don't have much to do again, I'm sure I'll go see it.
My dad and I had been joking about it all day, and when we walked by we decided "Hey, why not give it a try?".
I probably won't go to it a lot, but if I don't have much to do again, I'm sure I'll go see it.
fl_actuary
Member
I can't believe I missed this thread. We went on 1/29 (I think) and it was great. Much better production than I would have imagined.
Also, the comment about the first ticket being handed out in Feb had to be wrong. They made a big deal about the winner of todays (1/29) show getting a golden ticket.
I also have to add, I found a hidden mickey at the show. Made me feel all warm inside knowing that I was one of the first.
Also, the comment about the first ticket being handed out in Feb had to be wrong. They made a big deal about the winner of todays (1/29) show getting a golden ticket.
I also have to add, I found a hidden mickey at the show. Made me feel all warm inside knowing that I was one of the first.
Honor
Member
We enjoyed American Idol Experience
We visited the first week the Experience was open. No trouble getting seats. We went to an afternoon show and the final show of the day. All of the singers could at least carry a tune. All were better than the bad auditions they show for fun on the real American Idol. The singer we thought was best did not win. At the finale, there was one lady with a tremendous voice but she lost out to the last singer who saw a clap-a-long country song. I enjoyed his performance but she was the better singer. We will go back every time we're at Hollywood Studios ... and we're going back next week.
We visited the first week the Experience was open. No trouble getting seats. We went to an afternoon show and the final show of the day. All of the singers could at least carry a tune. All were better than the bad auditions they show for fun on the real American Idol. The singer we thought was best did not win. At the finale, there was one lady with a tremendous voice but she lost out to the last singer who saw a clap-a-long country song. I enjoyed his performance but she was the better singer. We will go back every time we're at Hollywood Studios ... and we're going back next week.