When we found out my son's marching band would be performing in February, we called immediately. The only rooms available were the pirate rooms. As people have said, that's not a good sign. But - I was glad they had something for the boys. There's so much for the girls.
The rooms had the fun, quirky, old-fashioned, in-your-face-theming that we expected from Disney in the past. No, they weren't perfect. Yes, they needed TLC. I don't know why Disney is avoiding their world-famous TLC for generic stuff or this "let's promote our latest, really bad, live action film that will bomb" in their resorts. Take care of the quality and the Guests will follow.
Perhaps these rooms weren't selling because they were in Trinidad - the farthest section of the resort from the main area - and not because of their theming??
Honestly, they were great for walking over the bridge and hopping on the Skyliner. We were at WDW - the magical world where reality doesn't exist. I wouldn't trade our experience - or our room for that trip - for anything.