Recently, Rotten Tomatoes did a countdown of the top fifty animated Disney movies of all-time and I was a little surprised by the results. Since I so disagreed with their rankings (and I think most Disney fans would) I have decided to make a list of my own. I will admit, even though I am a huge fan of all things Disney, I have not seen all fifty animated Disney movies. For the purposes of my rankings I will be listing the top thirty animated films. I have attempted to remove personal biases from my rankings, but cannot do so completely. Even though I try to be objective, I know that my own personal feelings about the films will have some impact on the rankings. However, I have also looked at several other factors such as artistic beauty, plot and character development, music, box office gross, innovation, and legacy in helping to rank these animated films. It should also be noted that I have not included Pixar movies in this list (I will save that for another day). Most importantly, I am not saying that my list is the be-all-end-all ranking of Disney animated movies. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and this one is mine.
I will begin the countdown with numbers 30 through 26. Please feel free to comment with your own opinions of these movies.
30. Great Mouse Detective (1986)
I will begin the countdown with numbers 30 through 26. Please feel free to comment with your own opinions of these movies.
30. Great Mouse Detective (1986)
- Rotten Tomatoes Rank: 31
- IMDB Rating: 7.2/10, Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 6.9/10
- Domestic Gross: $38.6 million
- Synopsis: Basil, the rodent Sherlock Holmes, investigates the kidnapping of a toy-maker and uncovers its link to his arch-enemy, Professor Ratigan, and a plot against the Crown itself.
- My Views: This is a very creative adaptation of Sherlock Holmes and is one of the darker Disney animated movies. It is a fast-paced adventure full of mystery and intrigue, but there are also some lighter moments that provide a release of tension. Basil might be one of the more clever and witty Disney characters, but he does not really receive much notoriety today, while Ratigan’s evil/creepy quality can be highly attributed to the great voice work of Vincent Price.
- Rotten Tomatoes Rank: 35
- IMDB Rating: 7.1/10, Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 6/10
- Domestic Gross: $22.2 million
- Synopsis: Animated version of the legend of King Arthur as he is raised and trained by the wizard, Merlin.
- My Views: It may not be the most traditional version of the legend of King Arthur, but it is certainly entertaining. The movie is just as much, if not more, about Merlin as it is Arthur and he is responsible for many of the movie’s funnier moments. The Sherman brothers provide the music for the film and, although it may not be some of their best know work, some of the songs (like “Higgatus Figgatus”) are very catchy. It is also a movie with a good message for younger viewers: the importance of an education not matter what career you seek.
- Rotten Tomatoes Rank: 42
- IMDB Rating: 6.7/10, Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 6.1/10
- Domestic Gross: $27.9 million
- Synopsis: The Rescue Aid Society agents, Bianca and Bernard, race to Australia to save a boy and a rare golden eagle from a murderous poacher.
- My Views: This is one instance where I thought a sequel was better than the original movie. This movie has much more action and adventure than the original in addition to its more exotic setting in Australia. What really impresses me about this movie is the cast, with Bob Newhart providing the voice of Bernard, Eva Gabor voicing Bianca, and John Candy providing much of the comedic relief as the albatross Wilbur. Not to be overlooked, Percival McLeach, voiced by George C. Scott, is one of my all-time favorite Disney villains.
- Rotten Tomatoes Rank: 39
- IMDB Rating: 6.2/10, Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 6.2/10
- Domestic Gross: $137.7 million
- Synopsis: An orphaned dinosaur raised by lemurs joins an arduous trek to a sanctuary after a meteorite shower destroys his family home.
- My Views: Visually this movie is absolutely amazing, combining live action backgrounds with digitally animated dinosaurs. It was actually the most expensive movie produced in 2000 and really took animated movies to an entirely new level; nothing of this magnitude had ever been attempted before. The stunning visuals are also enhanced by a powerful score by James Newton-Howard. While I am not a huge fan of including lemurs in a story about Dinosaurs, they help to convey the message of the importance of family and sticking together no matter what the conditions.
- Rotten Tomatoes Rank: 38
- IMDB Rating: 6.9/10, Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 6/10
- Domestic Gross: $17.5 million
- Synopsis: Upon Madame Adelaide Bonfamille's passing her cat Duchess and 3 kittens stand to inherit her fortune. But not if Edgar the butler can help it.
- My Views: This a very creative concept for a story and features some memorable characters, even though the villain is a butler who is more laughable than evil. It is definitely a movie with its fair share of comedic moments. The music is a little different from most Disney movies in that it is more jazzy, especially the movie’s best-know song “Everybody Wants to be a Cat.” There is great chemistry between the voice talents of Eva Gabor (also in The Rescuers) as Dutchess and Phil Harris (also in Jungle Book and Robin Hood) as Thomas O’Malley, which sometimes does not always come across through animation.