• The new WDWMAGIC iOS app is here!
    Stay up to date with the latest Disney news, photos, and discussions right from your iPhone. The app is free to download and gives you quick access to news articles, forums, photo galleries, park hours, weather and Lightning Lane pricing. Learn More
  • Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
    Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.

Modification Rule changes

nickys

Premium Member
Original Poster
The rules have been changed around modifying a reservation.

The dates of the original reservation can only be changed when the check-out date is within 11 months.

This stops walking, but also stops anyone extending a reservation beyond 7 days. You’ll have to wait until 11 months from the check-out date and try to book / extend then. No guarantee of getting one.

It’s a deal breaker for us. Unless we can get the second week it isn’t worth us coming. It also puts DVC members at a disadvantage compared to those booking a cash reservation.

Oops, forgot to link:

 
Last edited:

Doberge

True Bayou Magic
Premium Member
"Modifications to travel dates and room types on a confirmed reservation can only be made when the original check-out date is within 11 months of the modification request. You can still update Guest information or cancel the reservation."

Not the most precise wording there. As written it leaves open interpretation that "modification request" could be the new dates. For example, a reservation made 9/3 for 8/3 to 8/10 could be modified on 9/4 to be 8/4 to 8/11. The original checkout date 8/10 would be within 11 months of a "modification request" "8/4 to 8/11." Admittedly it's an aggressive interpretation but can be entirely avoided by wording as "when the original checkout date is within 11 months of the date the modification is requested."

also stops anyone extending a reservation beyond 7 days. You’ll have to wait until 11 months from the check-out date and try to book / extend then. No guarantee of getting one.

It’s a deal breaker for us. Unless we can get the second week it isn’t worth us coming.
I don't completely follow but if true I hope there's a workaround to allow member services to manually override in situations like this. Of course, it'd be an added pain point if needing to contact MS.
 

nickys

Premium Member
Original Poster
"Modifications to travel dates and room types on a confirmed reservation can only be made when the original check-out date is within 11 months of the modification request. You can still update Guest information or cancel the reservation."

Not the most precise wording there. As written it leaves open interpretation that "modification request" could be the new dates. For example, a reservation made 9/3 for 8/3 to 8/10 could be modified on 9/4 to be 8/4 to 8/11. The original checkout date 8/10 would be within 11 months of a "modification request" "8/4 to 8/11." Admittedly it's an aggressive interpretation but can be entirely avoided by wording as "when the original checkout date is within 11 months of the date the modification is requested."


I don't completely follow but if true I hope there's a workaround to allow member services to manually override in situations like this. Of course, it'd be an added pain point if needing to contact MS.

You’re stretching your interpretation!

The original checkout date in your example is 8/10. You can’t modify it until then. At which point you’re fighting for it with everyone else.

You can only extend the original reservation on 8/10. Which means there’s no guarantee of extending.

That’s very different to what I bought into DVC for, where as long as I could book the first night I was guaranteed to be able to book as many nights as I had points for. That’s a significant change IMO.
 

nickys

Premium Member
Original Poster
I’m glad they are taking more steps to curb commercial renting. Sorry to anyone who isn’t a renter who this effects I guess
This doesn’t do anything to stop commercial renters. It’s to stop walking.

Commercial renters don’t want the hassle of walking a reservation.
 

networkpro

Well-Known Member
In the Parks
Yes
Its still a major downfall of the system where its not based on dedicated dates, but points. Time share rooms dont expand and contract during and after peak demand times.
 

pdude81

Well-Known Member
Technically the check out day becomes within 11 months at midnight, where the opening for a new reservation begins at 8am. There is a world, albeit a strange one, where they can let you extend at that point.

I also am frustrated by this silliness, as someone who often stays for 8 nights. Given that they no longer do the dining workaround for 60 day reservations, that kind of forces a split stay on holiday weekends.
 

nickys

Premium Member
Original Poster
What exactly is this trying to prevent? What is “walking?”
Walking is where someone books a reservation well ahead of when they really want to stay. Then add days to the end and drop days at the beginning, thus moving the reservation forward until they have what they want.

Bill wants as Copper Creek studio from 5th - 12th December next year.
So on the 1st December they book Nov 1st - 8th in a Copper Creek studio.
On the 6th December they modify it to Nov 6th - 13th.
On the 11th December they modify to Nov 11th - 18th
And so on until they get to the 5th - 12th December.

It worked because if you have a room booked until a certain date (no more than 11 months + 7), noone else can grab that room from you until your checkout date. If you modify before the checkout date you can grab those extra days.

That system allowed you to add days to your reservation. But walking was a way to get the room you wanted at a busy time, by example exploiting the loophole of dropping days too.

However by locking a reservation from being modified until the checkout date, they prevent walking.

That’s good.

But if you want to stay longer than a week, you can’t extend the reservation until the checkout date, at which point others will be looking to book as well.

That’s not good if all you want is to stay for 10 days, 14 days or 21 days.
 
Last edited:

RememberWhen

Well-Known Member
I’m with you @nickys. And I have 100% walked reservations when I needed to to get what I wanted. I’m not opposed to making that impossible somehow, but we also often book more than 7 days and it doesn’t work to not be able to get the whole 10 when I already have flights and school plans sorted. The possibility that we might not get the last few nights is concerning.
 

pdude81

Well-Known Member
We'll have to see how this plays out. Will people now hold multiple rooms (overlapping reservations) at the same time in order to get what they want in chunks, and then shave days off later and merge the multiple reservations.

At least with walking you can predict and expect days to show back up on the front end and pick up the scraps.
 

Vacationeer

Well-Known Member
In the Parks
No
DVC decided 7 nights max is reasonable to secure past 11 months.

Less has been at a slight disadvantage. Now more is also. In either case you might have less room options to choose from than a person booking 7 nights. As someone who typically books between 4-9 nights I’m ok with the change. I didn’t like walking for a few reasons. Walking forced a much longer planning window than 11 months for high demand rooms. It also made a mess of inventory in the months preceding common goal dates.

Booking 9 nights might mean I need to be more flexible on my target dates and/or room size/view. That same thing happens for us with shorter trips. Other people got to pick through the inventory before us. Such is life in a timeshare when you don’t buy a guaranteed week or two.

As far as locking an 11 month reservation until 7 months when other resort owners can trade in so they can have a fair chance? That seems to go against our contracts saying home priority needs to be at least one month, regardless of when that window opens. It’s there for a reason. BVTC does not even have to exist, but our 1 month home priority does. I don’t think forcing the holding of home priority inventory into the 7 month window in order to make changes would jive legally.
 

OKW_Alan

New Member
The only time we had trouble getting a reservation at 11 months was this year in December. I assume it was because of walking but Dec is a busy time so maybe not. I've had problems several times getting a non-home resort reservation at 7 months. Unfortunately the new policy doesn't do anything to help with that. I hope they consider that in the future.
 

nickys

Premium Member
Original Poster
The only time we had trouble getting a reservation at 11 months was this year in December. I assume it was because of walking but Dec is a busy time so maybe not. I've had problems several times getting a non-home resort reservation at 7 months. Unfortunately the new policy doesn't do anything to help with that. I hope they consider that in the future.
At 7 months anyone can book a non-home resort. I’m not sure there’s anything they can do to improve your chances of switching to another resort.
 

OKW_Alan

New Member
At 7 months anyone can book a non-home resort. I’m not sure there’s anything they can do to improve your chances of switching to another resort.
I was thinking the same thing but it might be possible the system could identify non-home bookings at 7 months like a home booking at 11 months.
 

nickys

Premium Member
Original Poster
I was thinking the same thing but it might be possible the system could identify non-home bookings at 7 months like a home booking at 11 months.
Oh, so make the same change as they’ve made for 11 months?

But the change was to stop walking. At 7 months any owner could swoop in and block your walk anyway, so it’s not such a problem.

Availability of a room at 7 months is entirely down to demand. Stopping walking won’t change that.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom