Ha, I think I'm just about the only person on this board that actually LIKES Star Tours, LMA and the Indy show as is. Probably because I only have gotten to go to WDW every 5-6 years(hopefully I can correct that by saving up), and really, my last trip was the first time I actually checked out any shows.
So yeah, I really wouldn't change/remove Star Tours, LMA or the Indy show. However...
I would add an Indy dark ride. Hells yeah.
Let's put that big-______ hat someplace that makes a little sense.
Muppet dark ride? Yes please. One condition though, we must get cameos from Sesame Street, Fraggle Rock, Dark Crystal and Labryinth characters. Sesame Street most of all though.
New Star Wars ride? How about zipping through the forests of Endor on speeder bikes? Sign me up.
Is the MGM part of Disney-MGM Studios still there? Let's get an effing James Bond attraction, PLEASE. A Buzz Lightyear-style shoot'em ride, preferably.
Monorail stop, please!
WHERE IS ROGER RABBIT!?! I mean, come on, such a no-brainer.
Put a sweet Fantasia ride inside of Bald Mountain, please.
Either get rid of or MASSIVELY improve the Backlot Tour (bring back Herbie, you ________________!). Please.
I actually like the idea of a Harry Potter ride, but since the movies are handled by Warner Bros., I can't really see that happening. If this unlikely ride DID actually happen, I can't tell if I'd rather have it in MGM or in Fantasyland at MK...
Even though it would make WAY more sense in EPCOT or Tomorrowland, I still want to see a Tron ride, and I honestly wouldn't care if they stuck it in MGM. It IS a movie, so erm... yeah.
I'd love to see a Nightmare Before Christmas ride, but I feel like it'd make more sense in Fantasyland in the Magic Kingdom.
Either way, any/all of that stuff would be insanely awesome. But what I'd really, REALLY love to see...
Is a Godzilla ride. And no, not based on that godawful American travesty, I mean the REAL Godzilla. If Disney got together with Toho Studios and put together a Godzilla ride, I'd be constantly emptying my bowels with unspeakable delight.
I want to just barely dodge the scorching-hot atomic breath of a 150 foot tall invincible radioactive dinosaur from hell, and if anybody can pull that off, it's the big D. The ride can end with us witnessing an insane four way battle between Godzilla, Mothra, King Ghidorah and Mechagodzilla. Ideally, the ride would capture the movie series' transformation from nuclear apocalyptic horror to ridiculous '70's camp to something half-way between the two.
Equally improbable would be a shoot'em up ride based on Ghostbusters. I'd love to go on a ride where I sit in a tiny Ecto-1 and blast the crap out of Slimer. God, the grand finale with Mr. Stay-Puft would be mind-blowing... they could just recycle technology from the non-existent Godzilla ride.
Also, these last two rides will probably never happen, even though I want them SO BAD. Even more than James Bond, Roger Rabbit, Tron, Fantasia, Muppets, ANYTHING. MGM would instantly become my favorite park of all time if it got either one of those never-gonna happen rides. Sure, they're not very "Disney" but neither is Aerosmith, the Twilight Zone or Indiana Jones. That's whats so cool about MGM. It still has that Disney magic, but with the edginess and excitement of show-biz.