Genie+ doesn't include these though. These are all the rides that are extra per-ride, per-person ON TOP of Genie+.
I believe what he meant is the pay per rides on top of Genie (in his opinion) are NOT the best rides in the park. And I'm inclined to agree in some cases. Frozen is a VASTLY overrated ride. There is nothing better about Frozen then the Under the Sea Mermaid ride in MK. I cannot think of one single aspect that makes it better. Of course my daughter likes it but it is overrated. Remy makes sense to be on the top tier but nobody can call it the best ride yet when it is not even open. It can be argued that Soarin is by far the best ride in Epcot and Test Tracks 80 plus minute wait all day being avoided os a bonus as well. You can do the entire section formerly known as future world in half a day with Genie Plus. Even if they made TT the IAS and Frozen a Genei + ride, you are still looking at 2 rides that were previously tier 1s.
In MK SDMT is not nearly the best ride. I would gladly give that up for Big Thunder, Splash. Jungle cruise. Pirates and the Mansion in one day. Something I never accomplished when going on a busy week.
In HS you can go on Smugglers and MMRR the same day and still do TOT which is arguably one of the best rides.
You sound as if Genie is completely useless. If you feel that way then do not purchase it and go with the IAS rides instead. But there is the capability of it working to your advantage.
In my opinion the ride choices on the Genie + platform are pretty reasonable amd better tjen the tiers with FP. It becomes meaningless if there are availability issues though.