I stayed at the All-Star Sports for a week, April 9 - April 15. I have to tell you that my impressions were very high. The place was clean, room was comfortable (yes, small, but basically a standard room like in any motel), staff was incredible. Over and over the cast members went out of there way to make our stay pleasant.
Yes, there were spots that needed work, such as some of the decorations that flanked the tops of a couple of buildings needed to be redone. The hotel room was still carpeted, instead of a faux-wood, which would be more sanitary in a hotel room.
Still, the theming was whimsical and fun, and - while being arguably the least "Disney-like" of the value resorts - still had more than enough Disney atmosphere without being overwhelming. And I don't even like sports.
They are still doing work, but from time to time all resorts - even deluxe - have maintenance done. It wasn't an inconvenience to us in any way.
I was very impressed, and would stay there again with no regrets.