We've stayed at both All-Star Movies and Pop, and I'd have to give the edge to Pop as well. However, depending on what time of year you go, the values can be very crowded, and long walks to the bus station may not be avoidable. We had a great experience at both, but were there during low crowd times. The rooms are very small, but kids love the theming, and you don't spend much time in the rooms anyway. The one gripe was the buses - but that's really a value vs. mod/deluxe issue. If we were doing another value stay we'd probably go with Pop or AOA.