This is a great comparison, IMO, and also a perfect example of why I love WDW so much. Neither of these coasters are ever going to be recognized as among the best in the world based merely upon speed or height or drops, etc. But when you factor in theming and the queues and the unique nature of each ride overall, these are exactly the type of rides I that I find to be the most fun.
Oh, and it was razor close for me, but I went with EE.