I think when the Skyliner is there it's worth it.
Pop is a slight upgrade over the All Stars. However for Pop, I don't like the way the murphy bed for the extra bed is built into the wall. It looks weird and cheap when not being utilized.
The problem right now is there are alot less buses...
In theory on property is closer.
But that is really Determined by what park you want to go to.
Some of the offsite on West Irlo are just as close if not closer to AK than most of The Disney Resorts and Even The All Stars.
DoubleTree is close to Disney Springs (10 minute walk or resort shuttle...
Double tree Disney Springs.
Those are all suites so if someone sleeps on sofa in 2nd room you are fine.
Comes with Disney 60 day fp, extra extra magic hours and shuttle
Parking is an extra $15 bucks or so.
And 10 dollar resort fee