MEN IN BLACK Alien Attack vs Revenge of the Mummy

[DisneyAndUniversalFan]

Better ride?

 

[JT3000]

Men in Black. It's less thrilling but more coherent, and an overall better representation of its source material.

 

[jeanericuser001]

Men in Black is a ride with infinite rerideability because everyone will always want to compete to get that best score. The mummy is good as long as its working properly which it isn't always doing.

 

[Frankenstein79]

Men in Black almost made me puke the one time I rode it, so my vote goes to The Mummy.

 

[jeanericuser001]

Men in Black almost made me puke the one time I rode it, so my vote goes to The Mummy.

You must have been one of my many victims in MIB. Im notorious in the final phase for putting people in almost constant spin until the computers puts a stop to it.

 

[The Grand Inquisitor]

Better ride?

This is truly tough. I love both rides but I have to vote men in black. I could re ride it so many times. Both rides are truly spectacular.

 

[Robbydj13]

I have a strong love for the mummy ride when everything is working as it should

 

[Weather_Lady]

They're both great, but I think MIB enjoys the distinction of being the "best of its kind" -- meaning, it blows other competitive shooter attractions (e.g., Buzz Lightyear's Spaceranger Spin, Toy Story Midway Mania) out of the water, while presenting a coherent and enjoyable story.

The Mummy is a great attraction in its own right, but I do think there are other coasters that present a more coherent "story" line (I literally had to Google the Mummy's backstory the first time to figure out what was supposedly going on - the whole "you're in a museum -- no, a movie set -- no, an amusement park ride -- no, another dimension" mish-mash really threw me) and/or a more thrilling ride, so it suffers by comparison.

 

[Figgy1]

This is a difficult choice. My kids love both as do I. Both are excellent rides! I give a slight edge to Mummy because if I feel like skipping a ride to have a beverage it's just across the walkway to the pub The one and maybe only one good thing about having teens

 

[OG Runner]

Again Apples & Oranges. Both are fun rides. One is more interactive. One is a bit more thrilling. They are however very
different experiences and not ones that really compare well. How about the Mummy versus Gringott's? Spiderman versus
Transformers? The Hulk versus The Velocicoaster? (I know you can't yet.) But still they would be a more consistent comparison.