Being from NJ, I've really wanted to stay at the Boardwalk as well. The whole atmosphere is great, though- from the boardwalk promenade to the International Gateway gardens area (my personal favorite) to a scenic stroll around the lagoon.
Fun fact: Our family's yearly vacation spot in Stone Harbor, NJ shares the name of the concierge at the Beach Club, which is known as the "Stone Harbor Club".
Hey there- Huge fan of your avatar and user title. The Beach Club is my favorite resort, and I'd stay there every visit if I could. I actually have a picture identical to the one in your avatar, though it's considerably more cloudy (we were there in '04 and then in '08 with the tropical storm).