Woody13 said:There is no Disney family crest or coat of arms. What you see at the park is pure fiction.
monorail_man said:EVERY family has a coat of arms, and crest.
Woody13 said:Wrong, very few families have them. However, a lot of sales people would like to make you think that to be true. Don't be taken in by this hype. :wave:
College of Arms said:Q. Do coats of arms belong to surnames?
A. No. There is no such thing as a 'coat of arms for a surname'. Many people of the same surname will often be entitled to completely different coats of arms.
monorail_man said:I have done EXTENSIVE research on family crest and coats of arms. I have been researching my own for years.
Trust me, EVERY family name has a crest and coat of arms.
Woody13 said:Your research has failed you. Heraldry is rather rare. After all, you have to do something to gain heraldry. If it were given to every family, it would be totally worthless. Or do you have a different theory? :wave:
monorail_man said:You are confusing a family crest and coat of arms with a ROYAL Heraldry.
You are correct in that a heraldry is earned. However every family had a crest/coat to identify them.
Woody13 said:Sales people just love that way of thinking! However, no that is not true. I'm still waiting to hear your theory (if you have one).
Woody13 said:Why would a crest or coat of arms be designed for a family that were known to be thieves, pirates, common trash, etc?
Are we to assume that every family in the world has crest or coat of arms?
Woody13 said:Think about it for just a moment and then you might realize that that concept is unrealistic in the real world.
Woody13 said:Don't be fooled by people that desire to scam you! :wave:
monorail_man said:I am not stating "my theory", I am stating fact.
Woody13 said:You are stating your beliefs which are far from being factual. How could an Eskimo family have a crest or coat of arms? Are you so totally egocentric to the point that you ignore the real world? Show me the crest or coat for an unwritten family or culture language! :wave:
Woody13 said:[font=verdana, geneva, helvetica]Except for a few individual exceptions from some parts of Eastern Europe[font=verdana, geneva, helvetica], there is no such thing as a coat of arms for a surname - despite the claims and implications of some companies to the contrary. [/font][font=verdana, geneva, helvetica]Coats of arms are granted to individuals, not families or surnames. A form of property, coats of arms may rightfully be used only by the uninterrupted male line descendants of the person to whom the coat of arms was originally granted. Such grants were (and are) made by the proper heraldic authority for the country in question. [/font]
[font=verdana, geneva, helvetica]The next time you come across a product or scroll with a family coat of arms for your surname, remember that just because your surname is SMITH, for example, doesn't give you the right to any of the hundreds of coats of arms borne throughout history by others named SMITH. Therefore, how could an individual or company that has not researched your direct family tree know whether you have inherited the right to display a particular coat of arms? If you're looking for something fun then these items are OK, though misrepresentative, but if you're looking for something from your own family history, then stay away! [/font][font=verdana, geneva, helvetica]If you would like to learn if a coat of arms was awarded to your ancestor, you may want to try contacting the College of Arms or appropriate authority for the country you believe your ancestor was from and request a search in their records (they usually provide this service for a fee). In most countries you can also design and even register your own individual coat of arms based on the arms of someone who shared your surname, or from scratch to mean something special to your family and its history. :wave: [/font]
[/font]
Woody13 said:[size=+0]The Society for Creative Anachronism, Inc. (SCA) is a recreational and social group and has no accreditation or standing in the academic community. In short, the SCA is the last place to go if looking for accurate genealogical information.[/size]
[size=+0][/size]
[size=+0]To reiterate, there is no real Disney crest or coat of arms. However there is a fictional Disney coat of arms located on Cindy's Castle. The Disney coat of arms is located in Fantasyland for a good reason! :king: [/size]
monorail_man said:I have posted LOTS of facts and points, and yet you have posted nothing more then argument.
Woody13 said:You forgot one thing. You haven't posted any evidence to support your conclusion that a Disney coat of arms does indeed exist.
monorail_man said:ALL FAMILIES HAVE A CREST. DEPENDING ON THEIR LEVEL OF IMPORTAINCE THEY MAY HAVE A COAT OF ARMS, AND IF THEY ARE OF ROYAL DECENT THEY HAVE A HERALDRY.
monorail_man said:HERE is the best I have found for the Disney coat of arms.
Woody13 said:I can assure you that a grant of arms has never been awarded to a member of the Disney family. After all, wasn't that the question?
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.