Skinny Minnie Outrage

popcenturylover

Well-Known Member
That is horrible! Change the dress not, the character! They look disgusting & I hope that no one buys anything from them! (Barney's that is) What is Disney trying to teach our kids? That they aren't beautiful unless they are a size 0? I can't believe that they would partner up with another company that wants to change the size of the characters to fit into their dresses! Why not change the dress to fit the character?
 

wiigirl

Well-Known Member
I still think Skinny Minnie sounds like a drink... :p
75.gif
 

ExtinctJenn

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
That is horrible! Change the dress not, the character! They look disgusting & I hope that no one buys anything from them! (Barney's that is) What is Disney trying to teach our kids? That they aren't beautiful unless they are a size 0? I can't believe that they would partner up with another company that wants to change the size of the characters to fit into their dresses! Why not change the dress to fit the character?
See I guess for me... I see this from the other perspective. I find it funny that people are going so nuts over this. I look at it as artistic license and nothing that someone put so much thought into that they meant it to be offensive or even meant it to make a point. It's not like Disney is now changing the Minnie character as a result or anything. I just didn't see the big deal I guess. :)
 

LuLaSue

Well-Known Member
I posted this in the other thread...
Personally, I am not liking Skinny Minnie or Dieting Daisy all that much!​
They have taken the whimsy out of these adorable Disney characters.​
I don't think it sends a good message to our kids. Kids and Teens commonly struggle with self-esteem issues, which is normal during these years. Since they are still discovering who they are, ads like this may lead them to compare themselves to media celeb types. Kids need to build a solid foundation of self-worth and personal strength. Tweens need to feel more love for themselves! It's bad enough they look as magazine covers and compare themselves now they even see what used to be whimsical, feel good characters turn into long lean dieting machines.​
I personally think we need to cultivate gratitude for the body in any shape or size and what it is capable of. We need to find tools to enable our youth to let go of the tendency to be critical of themselves and judgmental of others.​
 

sweetpee_1993

Well-Known Member
I see it as an artistic interpretation. The article I read said the characters were being "portrayed" as runway models. Well, there ya go. Runway models are the equivalent of walking sticks. They have no shape. The "fashions" just sorta hang on them like if you put a dress on a coat rack. Runway models aren't attractive to me so obviously these stick-versions of our beloved characters hold no appeal to me.

As far as the outrage over the "message" sent to young people, it's just like everything else in this world. Parents should be actively guiding their children in what they are exposed to. You have to use every opportunity you can to illustrate important points or ideals. Don't think for a moment we haven't had many conversations with our teen boys about how mainstream representations of the human body (models) aren't realistic and place unnecessary self-image issues on healthy people who physically cannot obtain such gaunt appearances. My boys are especially aware of females and the struggle with self-image (they see me fighting my weight continually). It's stuff we discuss. So when my boys see these portrayals of Disney characters what they see are stylized charicatures and nothing more.
 

LuLaSue

Well-Known Member
I see it as an artistic interpretation. The article I read said the characters were being "portrayed" as runway models. Well, there ya go. Runway models are the equivalent of walking sticks. They have no shape. The "fashions" just sorta hang on them like if you put a dress on a coat rack. Runway models aren't attractive to me so obviously these stick-versions of our beloved characters hold no appeal to me.

As far as the outrage over the "message" sent to young people, it's just like everything else in this world. Parents should be actively guiding their children in what they are exposed to. You have to use every opportunity you can to illustrate important points or ideals. Don't think for a moment we haven't had many conversations with our teen boys about how mainstream representations of the human body (models) aren't realistic and place unnecessary self-image issues on healthy people who physically cannot obtain such gaunt appearances. My boys are especially aware of females and the struggle with self-image (they see me fighting my weight continually). It's stuff we discuss. So when my boys see these portrayals of Disney characters what they see are stylized charicatures and nothing more.

I applaud you! Communication and guidance are key for kids! Having body awareness for self and others leads to a world with less judgement, less criticism of themselves and others.
 

sweetpee_1993

Well-Known Member
I applaud you! Communication and guidance are key for kids! Having body awareness for self and others leads to a world with less judgement, less criticism of themselves and others.

Thank you! Yeah, I think it's important for the boys to know why the idealistic gaunt images you see are so unrealistic as well as what the results of always pushing such unrealistic representations of the human form really are. I'll be honest, it started with them asking me why I always think I'm fat because they don't think I am. The conversation took off from there and has come up many times since. Just last night my youngest was talking to me about it. Then, of course, teenage boys and all, the conversation shifted to what *they* deem as the "ideal" female form. Thankfully, the gaunt, shapeless images of females that the mainstream seems to prefer is not their thing. They prefer a softness, shape, and curves. Mission accomplished! Woot!
 

Eeyore

Mrs. WDWMAGIC [Assistant Administrator]
Premium Member
Here's what I wonder- How many kids walk by the window of Barney's in NYC? How many of them would have seen the runway segment that runs for a few seconds in a video in that window? How many kids all over the country are now seeing the images because of the protest and outrage? I think this is a classic case of making a mountain out of a molehill. Too many people expect society to parent their children for them.
 

sweetpee_1993

Well-Known Member
Here's what I wonder- How many kids walk by the window of Barney's in NYC? How many of them would have seen the runway segment that runs for a few seconds in a video in that window? How many kids all over the country are now seeing the images because of the protest and outrage? I think this is a classic case of making a mountain out of a molehill. Too many people expect society to parent their children for them.

You have a good point. Based on the artwork, I wonder if kids would even recognize them as "Minnie" & "Daisy". They really don't look like the characters we know & love. It's almost a more adult-intended interpretation.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom