DCL Revises Alcohol Policy

RoadTrip

Member
My goodness people. You're on a cruise... stop being so cheap and have a little fun. I've never carried alcohol onto the ship and don't know why anyone would want to. I would far rather have wine at dinner and a few drinks afterwards in one of the ship's great lounges than sit in my stateroom and drink. Alcohol prices at sea aren't bad at all compared to those in the Disney Parks.
 

wm49rs

A naughty bit o' crumpet
Premium Member
My goodness people. You're on a cruise... stop being so cheap and have a little fun. I've never carried alcohol onto the ship and don't know why anyone would want to. I would far rather have wine at dinner and a few drinks afterwards in one of the ship's great lounges than sit in my stateroom and drink. Alcohol prices at sea aren't bad at all compared to those in the Disney Parks.
Perhaps if DCL reduced its drink prices in kind with this change people wouldn't be quite so aggravated. But since a there's slim chance in that....
 

RoadTrip

Member
As for paying for watered-down drinks, that may be true of the daily drink specials on the pool deck, but I've never found it to be the case in the ship's clubs. My primary drinks are wine and martini's and there is virtually no way to water those down. But I also enjoy the Captain's Mai Tai's and always have been more than satisfied with the "bounce per ounce".
:D :p :D
 

sweetpee_1993

Well-Known Member
My goodness people. You're on a cruise... stop being so cheap and have a little fun. I've never carried alcohol onto the ship and don't know why anyone would want to. I would far rather have wine at dinner and a few drinks afterwards in one of the ship's great lounges than sit in my stateroom and drink. Alcohol prices at sea aren't bad at all compared to those in the Disney Parks.


It's not a matter of being cheap. DCL does not have a great selection of beer or wine. They don't carry all liquors. The bars aren't open early. I guarantee you my usual go-to isn't something they serve up. (sugar-free strawberry lemonade + Parrot Bay) I've been in a bar that technically wasn't open yet but we knew the bartender so he fixed us up for a pre-dinner martini at about 5:00. If he hadn't been there we'd have been SOL. What about single parents with small children who go to bed early but would like to sit in their verandah with a cocktail? Should they leave their child alone to run up to a bar? Even with carrying on 2 liter bottles on our Fantasy Western in Sept 2013 hubby and I racked up roughly $800-$900 in bar tabs. ((No, we were never drunk. We can hold our top shelf liquors.)) It's not about cheap. It's about convenience and having options Disney might not have on a cruise that already costs more (in many cases double or more) what the competition charges. If Disney is charging a premium they need to set themselves above the rest, not strive to align with everyone else.

Additionally, dropping this on guests already PIF & in the penalty phase is unfair to those guests who signed on with the understanding they would be able to bring what they want without limitations. They paid for 1 thing and will get another. There's at least a glimmer of hope that DCL may reconsider these people. I hope so because THAT is messed up.

Maybe the booze policy updates aren't a big deal to you but what happens when the next big change is something that does affect you? If everyone throws up their hands on this, what's next? Will you be happy when the things you find value in are done away with?
 

sweetpee_1993

Well-Known Member
Perhaps if DCL reduced its drink prices in kind with this change people wouldn't be quite so aggravated. But since a there's slim chance in that....
The wine prices are laughable. Even their wine packages. No stinkin way I'd spend that. I'm okay with $10-$12 for a full size martini depending on contents. Most expensive thing I've had on a Disney ship is a Moët Ice by the glass at $20. The cheapest I've found a full bottle at home is about $55 on sale. Usually it's more like $60 to $65. Moët Ice is served poured over ice and the bartender was fixing ours up with a generous fruit garnish....which unfortunately began my love affair with the stuff. I have a bottle in my fridge right now that I swear whispers my name every time I open the door.
 

RoadTrip

Member
Last time I was on a Disney Cruise (2013) my favorite martini (Bombay Sapphire) cost in the neighborhood of $9-$10. Since I pay $8 for that at chain restaurants here in West Podunk, Missouri I thought that price was pretty reasonable.
 

wm49rs

A naughty bit o' crumpet
Premium Member
Last time I was on a Disney Cruise (2013) my favorite martini (Bombay Sapphire) cost in the neighborhood of $9-$10. Since I pay $8 for that at chain restaurants here in West Podunk, Missouri I thought that price was pretty reasonable.
That's fine for you. Others appear to drink otherwise....
 

jaklgreen

Well-Known Member
I don't really drink. Maybe an occasional pina colada, so 1 or 2 drinks is my max. I cruise with my 2 girls. When they were younger I was busy watching them and did not feel like I needed to drink(like I said, I don't drink much so 1 drink packs a punch). Now that they are a bit older, I just find that I really do not need/crave the alcohol and do not drink while on the cruise. I honestly never thought "hey, my kids are asleep, I am going to drink alone in my room". That just seems weird to me. But I guess if you are used to drinking, I can see how this new policy is a disappointment. I have looked at the prices and they seem to be in line with the fruity/mixed drinks I would get locally. On a positive note, we save a bunch of money every year by not buying alcohol, like most people do throughout the year, so I am able to go to WDW/cruise 1-2 times a year.;)
 

sweetpee_1993

Well-Known Member
I don't really drink. Maybe an occasional pina colada, so 1 or 2 drinks is my max. I cruise with my 2 girls. When they were younger I was busy watching them and did not feel like I needed to drink(like I said, I don't drink much so 1 drink packs a punch). Now that they are a bit older, I just find that I really do not need/crave the alcohol and do not drink while on the cruise. I honestly never thought "hey, my kids are asleep, I am going to drink alone in my room". That just seems weird to me. But I guess if you are used to drinking, I can see how this new policy is a disappointment. I have looked at the prices and they seem to be in line with the fruity/mixed drinks I would get locally. On a positive note, we save a bunch of money every year by not buying alcohol, like most people do throughout the year, so I am able to go to WDW/cruise 1-2 times a year.;)
I don't drink often in my daily life. Maybe a cocktail while out to dinner on occasion. I don't need or crave it. I enjoy it. My boys are 17 & 19. I don't have to worry with looking after them much anymore. When we cruise we enjoy the relaxation and indulging in cocktails. Not a have-to thing. The fun doesn't hinge on the drinks. In fact, on our recent 14-night cruise we didn't drink hardly at all. Having the option is nice, though.

We typically travel to Disney or cruise 4+ times a year. As perks that make the product special fade so does our interest. I currently have 6 cruises booked thru the end of 2016. 3 of these are NOT Disney. I'm considering ditching the remaining 3 or seeking other options. The scale is tipping as I'm finding smarter ways to maximize my travel budget and still have stellar, memorable experiences. It's just not fun when you feel like you're spending more to get less. Then there's the middle finger from Mickey with these things.....
 

Sans Souci

Well-Known Member
I don't see what is so weird about having a night cap on your verandah with your partner/spouse/friend at the end of the night. I also don't see what is weird about enjoying a glass of wine with a book on your verandah enjoying the ocean breeze.

Some people eat dessert every day of their cruise. I don't. Vive la différence.
 

RoadTrip

Member
I don't see what is so weird about having a night cap on your verandah with your partner/spouse/friend at the end of the night. I also don't see what is weird about enjoying a glass of wine with a book on your verandah enjoying the ocean breeze.

Some people eat dessert every day of their cruise. I don't. Vive la différence.
As I remember the ships have a store on board that sells wines and liquor by the bottle. Wouldn't you be allowed to drink that in your stateroom? I don't believe the prices were outrageous because there was no U.S. tax to pay. Maybe not as cheap as you could buy it at home, but far cheaper than buying individual drinks. I generally order a drink to take back to my room when I leave the club for the evening.... they have no problem with you doing that. There are certainly options available to you.
 

wm49rs

A naughty bit o' crumpet
Premium Member
As I remember the ships have a store on board that sells wines and liquor by the bottle. Wouldn't you be allowed to drink that in your stateroom? I don't believe the prices were outrageous because there was no U.S. tax to pay. Maybe not as cheap as you could buy it at home, but far cheaper than buying individual drinks. I generally order a drink to take back to my room when I leave the club for the evening.... they have no problem with you doing that. There are certainly options available to you.
Curious that most of these "options" involve giving DCL more cash....
 

RoadTrip

Member
Curious that most of these "options" involve giving DCL more cash....
So you are not looking for the freedom to drink in your stateroom... just the ability to do it cheaply. That's cool... just don't hide it as only wanting to have the option of sitting on your veranda with a glass of wine. :)
 

wm49rs

A naughty bit o' crumpet
Premium Member
So you are not looking for the freedom to drink in your stateroom... just the ability to do it cheaply. That's cool... just don't hide it as only wanting to have the option of sitting on your veranda with a glass of wine. :)
I never said anything about verandas or wine.

And if by "cheaply" you mean less than what DCL charges, then yes. The cost of these voyages are enough that taking away such a perk isn't one that I'll blithely accept as another chance to give DCL even more of my funds....
 

RoadTrip

Member
I never said anything about verandas or wine.

And if by "cheaply" you mean less than what DCL charges, then yes. The cost of these voyages are enough that taking away such a perk isn't one that I'll blithely accept as another chance to give DCL even more of my funds....
Sorry. I was just generically addressing some of the arguments presented in this thread. I understand your point of view, but at the same time have a hard time getting too outraged when DCL policy just falls in line with the others. I figure not having a casino on the ship probably saves me $1,000 over the course of a cruise. I don't mind spending a little of that on liquor. And I would assume that is one of the reasons DCL is higher priced than the other lines. They do not have that major source of revenue.
 

jakeman

Well-Known Member
What @wogwog said in no way offends me. I get what his thought process was and I don't feel it diminishes the origins of the statement. I can keep in it context.
Eh...not really offensive, but more like swatting a fly with a Buick. There's not really any need to Godwin a thread about fruity drinks on a cruise ship. The point can be made without referencing, even peripherally, the Holocaust.

As for the actual topic...eh. Our experience with alcohol has been inconsistent on the cruises, from the unstaffed/closed bars on the Dream like you described, to fully stocked almost always open bars with several dozen different beers on the Magic.
 

sweetpee_1993

Well-Known Member
As I remember the ships have a store on board that sells wines and liquor by the bottle. Wouldn't you be allowed to drink that in your stateroom? I don't believe the prices were outrageous because there was no U.S. tax to pay. Maybe not as cheap as you could buy it at home, but far cheaper than buying individual drinks. I generally order a drink to take back to my room when I leave the club for the evening.... they have no problem with you doing that. There are certainly options available to you.
Actually, any alcohol purchased in the duty-free onboard is tagged, stored, and given to you on the final night of your cruise. It's not intended for onboard consumption. This is the way the duty-free shops work on every cruise ship that I know of.

The prices in the duty-free are pretty good. I've seen better in Mexican ports, however.
 

RoadTrip

Member
Actually, any alcohol purchased in the duty-free onboard is tagged, stored, and given to you on the final night of your cruise. It's not intended for onboard consumption. This is the way the duty-free shops work on every cruise ship that I know of.

The prices in the duty-free are pretty good. I've seen better in Mexican ports, however.
Thanks for the information. I was unaware of that.
 

sweetpee_1993

Well-Known Member
So you are not looking for the freedom to drink in your stateroom... just the ability to do it cheaply. That's cool... just don't hide it as only wanting to have the option of sitting on your veranda with a glass of wine. :)
Then there's the liquors, beer, and wine that DCL doesn't have onboard to serve. Last October I had Moet Ice by the glass in Diversions at the bargain price of $20/glass. On the Wonder's WBPC in May they didn't have it to serve. FYI, I can buy a full bottle of Moet Ice for $55 at my local grocery store. ;)
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom