WDW March Madness: Take 6

Wilt Dasney

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
The tradition that will not die....this is the 6th annual WDWMagic March Madness attraction tournament, where 64 of the most revered attractions on our favorite 47 square mile-playground duke it out for bragging rights as Numero Uno.

In past years, I've run this in a very similar format to the hoops orgy that inspired it, with four brackets populated with 16 diverse attractions seeded first to worst. But variety is the spice of life, so this year let's try something a little different.

In the past, some people have suggested that attractions be grouped together by theme instead of randomly jumbled together. After I picked this year's field, some natural groupings became apparent, so I decided to try this approach. The result is eight distinct groups seeded from 1 to 8. There are seven themes (spectacles, thrills, classics, education, interactivity, live performances, and characters) and one mishmash of leftovers. This will result in some really tough matchups right from the get-go.

Some more notes on this year's tournament: This is the first year of inclusion for the new Nemo attractions at Epcot and Animal Kingdom, as well as Magic Kingdom's new Mickey stage show and the Monsters Inc. comedy show in Tomorrowland. This also looks to be the final go-round for the old version of Mexico's boat ride in World Showcase, with the new version set to open soon.

Round one will take your votes for the next two days. After that, SpongeScott's concurrent NIT-style tournament of stores, restaurants, and attractions beyond the four theme parks will hold its first round, and we'll keep alternating like that.

Here's this year's bracket:

Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle vs. #8 SpectroMagic
#4 Wishes vs. #5 IllumiNations: Reflections of Earth
#3 Soarin' vs. #6 Tree of Life
#2 Spaceship Earth vs. #7 Fantasmic!

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad vs. #8 Body Wars
#4 Kali River Rapids vs. #5 Liberty Belle Riverboat
#3 Cranium Command vs. #6 Star Tours
#2 Great Movie Ride vs. #7 Primeval Whirl

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic vs. #8 Tom Sawyer Island
#4 MuppetVision 3-D vs. #5 Monsters Inc. Laugh Floor Comedy Club
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug vs. #6 "Honey, I Shrunk the Audience"
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin vs. #7 Rafiki's Planet Watch

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris vs. #8 Innoventions
#4 Maelstrom vs. #5 Ellen's Energy Adventure
#3 El Rio del Tiempo vs. #6 Hall of Presidents
#2 The American Adventure vs. #7 Living with the Land

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King vs. #8 Voyage of the Little Mermaid
#4 Beauty and the Beast: Live on Stage vs. #5 Finding Nemo: The Musical
#3 Dream Along with Mickey vs. #6 Lights, Motors, Action! Extreme Stunt Show
#2 Indiana Jones Epic Stunt Spectacular! vs. #7 Flights of Wonder

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion vs. #8 Country Bear Jamboree
#4 Tomorrowland Transit Authority vs. #5 Jungle Cruise
#3 Big Thunder Mountain Railroad vs. #6 Walt Disney's Carousel of Progress
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean vs. #7 "it's a small world"

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party vs. #8 Goofy's Barnstormer
#4 The Seas with Nemo & Friends vs. #5 Journey into Imagination with Figment
#3 Peter Pan's Flight vs. #6 Stitch's Great Escape!
#2 Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party vs. #7 The Many Adventures of Winnie-the-Pooh

Thrills & Chills
#1 Splash Mountain vs. #8 Mission: SPACE
#4 Expedition Everest vs. #5 Space Mountain
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster vs. #6 DINOSAUR
#2 Twilight Zone Tower of Terror vs. #7 Test Track
 

SpongeScott

Well-Known Member
Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle
#5 IllumiNations: Reflections of Earth
#3 Soarin'
#7 Fantasmic!

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad
#4 Kali River Rapids
#3 Cranium Command
#2 Great Movie Ride

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#5 Ellen's Energy Adventure
#6 Hall of Presidents
#2 The American Adventure

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King
#4 Beauty and the Beast: Live on Stage
#6 Lights, Motors, Action! Extreme Stunt Show
#7 Flights of Wonder

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#4 Tomorrowland Transit Authority
#6 Walt Disney's Carousel of Progress
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party
#4 The Seas with Nemo & Friends
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#7 The Many Adventures of Winnie-the-Pooh

Thrills & Chills
#1 Splash Mountain
#4 Expedition Everest
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster
#7 Test Track

Some VERY tough picks in there for me.:brick:
 

GenerationX

Well-Known Member
Brilliant bracket breakdown, brother!

Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle
#5 IllumiNations: Reflections of Earth
#3 Soarin'
#7 Fantasmic!

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad
#4 Kali River Rapids
#3 Cranium Command
#2 Great Movie Ride

Interactive Adventures
#8 Tom Sawyer Island
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#5 Ellen's Energy Adventure
#6 Hall of Presidents
#7 Living with the Land

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King
#5 Finding Nemo: The Musical
#6 Lights, Motors, Action! Extreme Stunt Show
#7 Flights of Wonder

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#5 Jungle Cruise
#3 Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party
#4 The Seas with Nemo & Friends
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#7 The Many Adventures of Winnie-the-Pooh

Thrills & Chills
#1 Splash Mountain
#4 Expedition Everest
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster
#2 Twilight Zone Tower of Terror
 

Monty

Brilliant...and Canadian
In the Parks
No
Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle
#5 IllumiNations: Reflections of Earth
#3 Soarin'
#7 Fantasmic!

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad vs. #8 Body Wars
#4 Kali River Rapids
#6 Star Tours
#7 Primeval Whirl

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#4 Maelstrom
#3 El Rio del Tiempo
#2 The American Adventure

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King
#4 Beauty and the Beast: Live on Stage
#6 Lights, Motors, Action! Extreme Stunt Show
#7 Flights of Wonder

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#4 Tomorrowland Transit Authority
#3 Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party
#4 The Seas with Nemo & Friends
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#7 The Many Adventures of Winnie-the-Pooh

Thrills & Chills
#8 Mission: SPACE
#4 Expedition Everest
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster
#2 Twilight Zone Tower of Terror
 

MouseMadness

Well-Known Member
I LOVE MARCH MADNESS!!! :sohappy:

(Did I ever tell you that it's my namesake? Or I'm it's namesake... something :lookaroun :shrug: )

Okay...

Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle
#4 Wishes
#3 Soarin'
#2 Spaceship Earth
(Well! That was easy :lookaroun )
Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad
#4 Kali River Rapids
#3 Cranium Command
#2 Great Movie Ride
(again, easy :lol: BJ are you purposefully putting all my favorites first? :lookaroun )
Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin
(Hmmmm.... :lookaroun)
Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#4 Maelstrom
#3 El Rio del Tiempo
#2 The American Adventure
:eek:
Live Entertainment
#8 Voyage of the Little Mermaid
#5 Finding Nemo: The Musical (which I can only assume I'll like better :dazzle: )
#6 Lights, Motors, Action! Extreme Stunt Show
#7 Flights of Wonder

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#4 Tomorrowland Transit Authority
#3 Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
#7 "it's a small world"

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party
#4 The Seas with Nemo & Friends
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#7 The Many Adventures of Winnie-the-Pooh

Thrills & Chills
#1 Splash Mountain
#4 Expedition Everest
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster
#2 Twilight Zone Tower of Terror
 

Laura

22
Premium Member
Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle
#4 Wishes
#3 Soarin'
#2 Spaceship Earth

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad
#4 Kali River Rapids
#6 Star Tours
#2 Great Movie Ride

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#4 Maelstrom
#3 El Rio del Tiempo
#7 Living with the Land

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King
#5 Finding Nemo: The Musical
#3 Dream Along with Mickey
#2 Indiana Jones Epic Stunt Spectacular!

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#4 Tomorrowland Transit Authority
#3 Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party
#5 Journey into Imagination with Figment
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#2 Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

Thrills & Chills
#1 Splash Mountain
#5 Space Mountain
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster
#2 Twilight Zone Tower of Terror

Happy 3-5. :)
 

dopey

New Member
Aw, man, the Bears are a #8 seed?!!! Do we have odds on any of these matchups? Oh, well, here goes (and let the trash-talking begin!):

Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle
#5 IllumiNations: Reflections of Earth
#3 Soarin'
#2 Spaceship Earth

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad
#4 Kali River Rapids
#6 Star Tours
#2 Great Movie Ride

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#6 "Honey, I Shrunk the Audience"
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#5 Ellen's Energy Adventure
#3 El Rio del Tiempo
#2 The American Adventure

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King
#4 Beauty and the Beast: Live on Stage
#3 Dream Along with Mickey
#2 Indiana Jones Epic Stunt Spectacular!

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#5 Jungle Cruise
#3 Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party
#4 The Seas with Nemo & Friends
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#2 Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

Thrills & Chills
#1 Splash Mountain
#4 Expedition Everest
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster
#2 Twilight Zone Tower of Terror
 

Computer Magic

Well-Known Member
Hurt Eisner Heal Mickey....wait wrong game. And Christy, I never knew that about you screen name

Icons & Jaw-droppers

#8 SpectroMagic
#4 Wishes
#3 Soarin' vs.
#2 Spaceship Earth

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad
#4 Kali River Rapids
#3 Cranium Command
#2 Great Movie Ride

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic (although I was ditched for this show :lookaroun )
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
Ellen's Energy Adventure
#6 Hall of Presidents
#2 The American Adventure

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King
#5 Finding Nemo: The Musical
#3 Dream Along with Mickey
#7 Flights of Wonder

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#4 Tomorrowland Transit Authority
#6 Walt Disney's Carousel of Progress
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party
#4 The Seas with Nemo & Friends
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#2 Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

Thrills & Chills
#1 Splash Mountain
#4 Expedition Everest
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster
#2 Twilight Zone Tower of Terror
 

dopey

New Member
Only losers would pick Fantasmic! over Spaceship Earth. Compare the ratings, guys. Geez, some people's children... :hammer: :p :D
 

Wilt Dasney

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Only losers would pick Fantasmic! over Spaceship Earth. Compare the ratings, guys. Geez, some people's children... :hammer: :p :D

Ratings go out the window in March. :D (If you thought George Mason was a Cinderella story, we've got the real thing...)
 

nighttimewisher

Well-Known Member
My first March Madness! :sohappy:

Icons & Jaw-droppers
#8 SpectroMagic
#4 Wishes
#6 Tree of Life
#7 Fantasmic!

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad
#4 Kali River Rapids
#6 Star Tours
#2 Great Movie Ride

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#6 "Honey, I Shrunk the Audience"
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#5 Ellen's Energy Adventure
#6 Hall of Presidents
#2 The American Adventure

Live Entertainment
#8 Voyage of the Little Mermaid
#4 Beauty and the Beast: Live on Stage
#6 Lights, Motors, Action! Extreme Stunt Show
#2 Indiana Jones Epic Stunt Spectacular!

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#5 Jungle Cruise
#3 Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#8 Goofy's Barnstormer
#5 Journey into Imagination with Figment
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#7 The Many Adventures of Winnie-the-Pooh

Thrills & Chills
#8 Mission: SPACE (hardest choice!)
#4 Expedition Everest(hardest choice no2!)
#6 DINOSAUR
#2 Twilight Zone Tower of Terror (hardest choice no3!)
 

DarkImage4

Member
AWESOME SET UP!!!! You know, I think I put WAY too much thought into this the one year that I ran it....anyways....

Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle
#5 IllumiNations: Reflections of Earth
#3 Soarin'
#2 Spaceship Earth

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad
#4 Kali River Rapids
#6 Star Tours
#2 Great Movie Ride

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#5 Ellen's Energy Adventure
#3 El Rio del Tiempo
#2 The American Adventure

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King
#5 Finding Nemo: The Musical
#3 Dream Along with Mickey
#2 Indiana Jones Epic Stunt Spectacular!

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#4 Tomorrowland Transit Authority
#3 Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party
#5 Journey into Imagination with Figment
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#7 The Many Adventures of Winnie-the-Pooh

Thrills & Chills
#8 Mission: SPACE
#5 Space Mountain
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster
#7 Test Track
 

k.hunter30

New Member
GO BUTLER BULLDOGS! Ok... back to Disney...

Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle
#4 Wishes
#6 Tree of Life
#2 Spaceship Earth

Grab Bag
#1 Walt Disney World Railroad
#5 Liberty Belle Riverboat
#6 Star Tours
#2 Great Movie Ride

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#5 Ellen's Energy Adventure
#3 El Rio del Tiempo
#7 Living with the Land

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King
#4 Beauty and the Beast: Live on Stage
#3 Dream Along with Mickey
#2 Indiana Jones Epic Stunt Spectacular

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion

#4 Tomorrowland Transit Authority
#3 Big Thunder Mountain Railroad
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas

#4 The Seas with Nemo & Friends
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#7 The Many Adventures of Winnie-the-Pooh
Thrills & Chills
#1 Splash Mountain

#5 Space Mountain
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster

#2 Twilight Zone Tower of Terror


Um... and how are the ride winners determined? (Can you tell I'm new to the Disney March Madness?:lookaroun )
 

nibblesandbits

Well-Known Member
Yay!!! March Madness is back!!!

Icons & Jaw-droppers
#1 Cinderella Castle
#4 Wishes
#6 Tree of Life
#2 Spaceship Earth

Grab Bag
#8 Body Wars
#4 Kali River Rapids
#6 Star Tours
#2 Great Movie Ride

Interactive Adventures
#1 Mickey's PhilharMagic
#4 MuppetVision 3-D
#3 It's Tough to be a Bug
#2 Buzz Lightyear's Space Ranger Spin

Learning Experiences
#1 Kilimanjaro Safaris
#5 Ellen's Energy Adventure
#6 Hall of Presidents
#2 The American Adventure

Live Entertainment
#1 Festival of the Lion King
#5 Finding Nemo: The Musical
#3 Dream Along with Mickey
#2 Indiana Jones Epic Stunt Spectacular!

Classic Favorites
#1 Haunted Mansion
#4 Tomorrowland Transit Authority
#6 Walt Disney's Carousel of Progress
#2 Pirates of the Caribbean

Character Corner
#1 Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party
#5 Journey into Imagination with Figment
#3 Peter Pan's Flight
#2 Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

Thrills & Chills
#1 Splash Mountain
#5 Space Mountain
#3 Rock n Roller Coaster
#7 Test Track


(Is this harder this year???)
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom