Probably the most convincing argument I have heard against a 5th gate deals with the theory that even its current state the average family can not do everything that WDW already has to offer during an average stay and a 5th gate would not generate more business but simply take away business from the other parks. If that theory is correct then there is little likelihood of Disney investing more than a billion dollars in a 5th gate that will not develop more income.
One could argue that Disney's current strategy of getting people to stay on property more and for longer periods could be laying the ground work, even if it is indirectly, for the need of a 5th gate. Even though Disney has set records in attendance for the last 2 years I still feel that we are way off from the attendance numbers needed to justify a 5th gate. When we see attendance rise to the point that at least phase 1 capacity closures start occurring outside of the holiday seasons, 5th gate will get some serious consideration.
One could argue that Disney's current strategy of getting people to stay on property more and for longer periods could be laying the ground work, even if it is indirectly, for the need of a 5th gate. Even though Disney has set records in attendance for the last 2 years I still feel that we are way off from the attendance numbers needed to justify a 5th gate. When we see attendance rise to the point that at least phase 1 capacity closures start occurring outside of the holiday seasons, 5th gate will get some serious consideration.