I saw a test show in December and I thought it need more work and was in no way ready for prime time. Putting the computer glitches aside as that will be worked out, the entry way reminded me of the Animation Tour in MGM. I thought the theatre looked really neat, just like a comedy club set up which it is supposed to be, but with a cartoonish flare.
Roz was totally hysterical and her character was great and any more they could do with her would be funny. She is just so crabby and cynical which is what makes her funny, just like Crush because he is so out there and laid back like a sterotype surfer dude.
Mike's nephew was not bad, he was pretty good. The other two monsters were not funny and the jokes and things they did reminded me of a Bugs Bunny cartoons. In the audience I was in, only the kids were laughing at the jokes and it almost sounded like a forced laugh because I think they thought they had to laugh. Almost none of the adults were laughing, except at the beginning with Roz.
I thought that there were things missing from the show, namely Sully and Boo. Maybe Boo could terrorize the new comedians. I thought that Sully should have come in at the end to save the day and put them over the laugh quota (which is something I told the imagineers at the end when we walked up and spoke with them).
Turtle Talk is far better and it has repeatability for me and blows the laugh floor away. In the current shape of the laugh floor, I could see it once and not see it again unless I was with someone who hadn't seen it and wanted to go. I think this show has great potential to be funny, they just needs to work it a bit better with the commedians.