I'm pretty sure we got whole milk by the half gallon at the Beach Club Marketplace last month. I asked my husband and he swore it was whole too. But this was not a small container and neither of us is 100% sure. I cannot for the life of me remember what was offered in the smaller containers. Normally we do a grocery run but being there 2 nights made us just say forget it for such a short stay.
Wow! 1. We are going in 41 days. 2. We are staying at YC, so the Beach Club Marketplace will be convenient if I can't find it at YC. We are there for 5 days in a club level room, so will have the mini fridge, but hopefully won't need to put much else in the fridge. We are just in a predicament because my son will be 14 months, so still very much in need of whole milk, and my daughter is 4, so too old for whole, but can get by on 1 or 2%.
Oh how fun! Yes, the marketplace will be super convenient for you! If you happen to have an AP it's 20% off there too right now. I understand about the desire for certain milks at certain ages. As I said our 9yo still gets whole at home, but not as picky out and about. Most restaurants are 1 or 2% You can likely ask for whole or skim at sit downs. The carton/jug milks are at the QS locations so it's more of what they have on hand.
We went to Disney last September, leaving on the 23rd. My youngest daughter turned one on September 16th. I actually kept her on a formula for a few extra weeks (til the day we got home on 10/1) for this very reason. I knew it would be easier packing formula than searching for whole milk. Just a bit of a side note, we invested in HydroFlask water bottles several years. We bought them specifically for Disney but we use them quite often at home too. When we have a zoo day for example, I can fill it with milk, pop in a few ice cubes, and the milk stays ice cold all day. Even in the hot Florida sun, our drinks stay icy cold all day 
Not all villas have a full size fridge. The studios have a mini fridge.
Your best bet would be something like this as far as whole milk goes, you could get it delivered to your resort, and it's shelf stable so you don't have to worry about them keeping it cold until you get it. And depending on the size of the fridge in your room it's more convenient for that too. https://www.amazon.com/Organic-Valley-Whole-Milk-6-75/dp/B00WVSNJ8Y?th=1
I do know that. I always refer to the studios specifically as "studios" so I wasn't including them in my thought when I mentioned "villas". I think of "villas" as the ones with a full kitchen and a living room separate from the bedroom. I'll keep in mind in the future that not everyone separates the two when referring to "villas".
There is both whole and skim milk available in the club level lounge at Yacht Club. They only put out the low fat ( I can't recall whether it's 1% or 2%) but you can request the others from a lounge cast member and they'll go get it from their service room. The lounge isn't open between 10PM and 7AM so you'll need to plan for those hours. It also shuts down for an hour twice a day.
Not everyone does because they're ALL villas, so perhaps you should just refer to them all correctly by changing your way of thinking, and it will be easier for all.
This is so good to know! He only has milk 3x a day, so we can try and work around this. Do you think they'd give me like 3 cartons to take back to the room?
I'm not sure that every type comes in individual containers. I've only seen them bring out a small pitcher upon request. They're very generous though so I feel certain that 3 times a day will be no problem. I just don't know if there are cartons. They do always have to-go cups with lids in the lounge so maybe you could make those work.
It has been so long since we did club level (thanks to DVC) I forgot about the cookies and milk. I am sure based on our history (and probably yours) that the CMs at the club lounge will be more than helpful this kind of a request. The to go cups should work too.
These are great, but as an FYI to the OP they do taste differently than refrigerated milk. The first few times my son was not a huge fan of them but he got used to it and became a great option for his lunches at preschool (no cafeteria)
I have the same family as you but opposite genders lol 4 year old boy and 14 month old girl. we are going in 20 days.
Thanks for the input! YC has been on my bucket list for so long, so I'm sooooo excited! I think we'll be okay for my older daughter, just mainly concerned with the whole milk for my son.
